

2023 · 1h 25m · Movie
After leaving her Amish community in her youth, a New York book editor finds herself in desperate need of a new cookbook to save her job. With Christmas on the horizon Sarah heads back to her family farm to reconnect. But with the presence of a handsome local—an outsider, but one that is friendly with the Amish community—he and Sarah sense chemistry and work together to save her family’s Amish bakery (developing an Amish Christmas Cookbook in the process).
Streaming on Prime Video +3
Digital release: December 10, 2023
Included with a subscription
Rent
Buy
Streaming data by JustWatch
Tap a star to rate this movie
Brandon Fox
Abram
No verified Instagram accounts found for this show.
Browse #christmasattheamishbakery on Instagram →Christmas at the Amish Bakery (2023)
IMDb · Mar 17, 2026
The Best & Battiest Moments From This Past Weekend's Holiday Movies
TVLine · Oct 16, 2025
Crowdsource Murder: All Filming Locations and Cast Details
The Cinemaholic · Jan 24, 2024
What to Watch on TV: The Gilded Age, Sullivan’s Crossing, and Reacher
Tell-Tale TV · Dec 10, 2023
Sunday, Dec. 10: DJ Jazzy Jeff and the Fresh Prince Reunite for 'A Grammy Salute to 50 Years of Hip-Hop'
StayTuned Magazine · Dec 10, 2023
Lifetime Christmas movie, five others are being filmed in this Kentucky city this year
Lexington Herald Leader · Apr 17, 2023